Skip to main content

Alexander Hamilton on the role of states vs. the federal government

I have been watching the "John Adams" miniseries on HBO, and it has me fairly obsessed (my wife is getting a little irritated with me starting every sentence with "methinks").  It has gotten me thinking about the founders, and what they envisioned.  I came across this quote from Alexander Hamilton in #45 of The Federalist Papers:
The powers delegated by the proposed Constitution to the federal government are few and defined. Those which are to remain in the State governments are numerous and indefinite. The former will be exercised principally on external objects, as war, peace, negotiation, and foreign commerce; with which last the power of taxation will, for the most part, be connected. The powers reserved to the several States will extend to all the objects which, in the ordinary course of affairs, concern the lives, liberties, and properties of the people, and the internal order, improvement, and prosperity of the State.
 Sometimes people will say that the Constitution was written to strengthen the federal government, and it was.  However, even a strengthened federal government via the Constitution was still significantly smaller and more limited (especially in times of peace) than the state governments, and as Hamilton states, they viewed state governments as being responsible for seeing to the welfare of citizens.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Some interesting facts about Georgia

Always eager to educate as well as persuade, Oregon Elephant has dug up the following interesting facts about Georgia: The highest point in Georgia is Mount Shkhara (5,201 m). It is known that people inhabited Georgia from very early times. Skulls of early man have been found in the country dating back 1.7 million years. People have lived in Tbilisi since the fourth millennium BC. The name of the present-day capital, Tbilisi, is derived from the Georgian word for warm. In Greek and Roman times the western part of Georgia was called Kolkheti (Colchis); the eastern part of the country was known as Iberia. Ancient myth says that the King of Colchis (Aeetes) possessed a Golden Fleece. The story of Jason and the Argonauts is about the quest for the fleece. Early Georgian merchants sailed as far as the Indian Ocean to trade their goods and bring back spices. The Silk Road, the trade route between Europe and China , ran through Phazisi. St Nino of Cappadoccia, a relative of St George, conv...

John McCain and George H.W. Bush...Separated at Birth?

...have you noticed the similarities (I know they're not identical) between the candidacies of John McCain and George H.W. Bush? Both men: were decorated military veterans had lost nomination fights in the past had extensiive foreign policy resumes criticized for being less interested in domestic politics criticized for being a moderate, not being conservative enough. True enough...McCain and George HW...seperated at birth.

Jeff Kropf and Merit Pay for Oregon Public Officials

You can read here about a massive pay raise for the Governor, judges and legislators being proposed by a state commission. Wow...and this, in the middle of economic crisis in the U.S. Jeff Kropf has an interesting idea...merit pay for public officials. I'm not against the idea...but how would you measure it? It would seem to me that any system of evaluation for politicians would inevitably become partisan (liberals might see cutting taxes as bad, if public services were reduced...conservatives might see passing a gun control law as bad, etc.). Anyway...it's an interesting idea...and certainly worth examining.