Skip to main content

BlueOregon's Carla Axtman and the liberal-conservative divide

Recently, BlueOregon’s Carla Axtman took Oregon GOP Party Chair Bob Tiernan to task for saying that government should be run like a business:

Ummm...okay Bob. You guys have been telling us that you're "running the country
(state) like a business" for years. Our government isn't a business or any other
for-profit enterprise. Its a structure that's supposed to protect the rights of
the people. Y'know..that whole life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness
thing.

I realize that there's going to be an ideological divide on
how to repair the mess we're in. But its going to be tough to get started if
only one of us (not you) understands the basic premise of government.

My take:
I think she entirely misses the point, and then arrogantly attacks Tiernan’s statement by accusing him of not understanding the basic premise of government. When a conservative says that a government should be run like a business, they mean that there should be some sense of accountability. A business is accountable in that if it doesn’t turn a profit, it fails (well, unless it’s a big bank, that is). Government, too often, finances its failure by simply borrowing more money. Also, because government has the power to tax, it can increase its revenue by simply taxing more – business can’t increase its available tax flow so easily – it has to actually do a better job of providing goods and services.

Conservatives (and even right-leaning moderates like me) think that government should be restrained in its reach...that it should be limited to those things that truly do promote liberty, rather than being expansive and all-encompasing.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Gov. Kulongoski wants to make a "green school" in Vernonia...hopefully the kids will get taught, also

Governor Ted is assembling a team to ask the feds for stimulus money to rebuild a school in Vernonia, damaged by the flooding in 2007. I think this is great - schools are a good thing to spend stimulus money on. But...then his train goes off the tracks... He wants to make the main thrust of the request that we will build a "green school"...now, I'm not opposed to doing responsible things to care for the environment, but I'm guessing doing extra stuff out of the ordinary, would make it much more expensive. With our economy the way it is, I just think that the people in charge of giving the money out are going to look at what can be done in a state, and how cost-effectively it can be done. If Oregon wants $5 million (I'm just making these numbers up) for a school to teach 1000 students, and Arizona will build a school, with the same facilities, same everything else, except they can do it for $3 million becuase it isn't a "green" school, and that m...
Post a Comment
Read more

John McCain and George H.W. Bush...Separated at Birth?

...have you noticed the similarities (I know they're not identical) between the candidacies of John McCain and George H.W. Bush? Both men: were decorated military veterans had lost nomination fights in the past had extensiive foreign policy resumes criticized for being less interested in domestic politics criticized for being a moderate, not being conservative enough. True enough...McCain and George HW...seperated at birth.
1 comment
Read more

Some interesting facts about Georgia

Always eager to educate as well as persuade, Oregon Elephant has dug up the following interesting facts about Georgia: The highest point in Georgia is Mount Shkhara (5,201 m). It is known that people inhabited Georgia from very early times. Skulls of early man have been found in the country dating back 1.7 million years. People have lived in Tbilisi since the fourth millennium BC. The name of the present-day capital, Tbilisi, is derived from the Georgian word for warm. In Greek and Roman times the western part of Georgia was called Kolkheti (Colchis); the eastern part of the country was known as Iberia. Ancient myth says that the King of Colchis (Aeetes) possessed a Golden Fleece. The story of Jason and the Argonauts is about the quest for the fleece. Early Georgian merchants sailed as far as the Indian Ocean to trade their goods and bring back spices. The Silk Road, the trade route between Europe and China , ran through Phazisi. St Nino of Cappadoccia, a relative of St George, conv...
Post a Comment
Read more